Discussion

Glock 19 vs Sig P365 vs S&W Shield Plus for daily carry — talk me out of overthinking this

Rangium Community TeamStarter contentMar 25, 2026

I've been carrying a full size for a year and I'm tired of dressing around it in summer. Looking hard at the P365, the Shield Plus, and just running a G19 in a better holster. I have medium-large hands and care most about reliability and a usable trigger. Curious what folks who've owned more than one of these actually settled on.

5 comments 0 views

Comments (5)

Example replies (5)

Starter content written by the Rangium team to seed the community.

I carry a 365 weekdays and a 19 on weekends when I'm dressed bigger. No rule says you only get one.
I went P365 to G19 and back. With the right holster and belt the 19 disappears better than people think, but the 365 wins on the hottest days. Honestly both are right answers.
The belt and holster matter more than which gun. A floppy belt makes any of these miserable. Spend the money there.
Shield Plus trigger is the best of the three stock IMO. Capacity is close enough to the 365 now that it's a real contender again.
Big hands + P365 can mean pinky float. Try the 365XL grip module, it fixed that complaint for me completely.